Chapter 47
Sam didn't reply right away. He looked at Chloe seriously. It was clear from her gaze that she wouldn't back down no matter what. She had set her sights on him, and she wouldn't let him go.
He was touched by her love and determination. A part of him wanted to accept her, to kiss her and fuck her like she wanted. But a bigger part of him was afraid.
'What should I do? Can I even have three relationships simultaneously? I'm already fucking my stepmom. Now you want me to fuck you too? Am I really a pervert who loves fucking his own family? Will things get so messed up? Will it ruin us all?'
It was too much for him to handle. But one thing was clear. Sam didn't want to run away from the situation either. He wanted to face it and be honest about his feelings.
"I don't want to hurt anyone, Chloe," Sam said in a low voice, holding her close. "I care about you so much, and I can't deny my attraction to you. I want you; I want to be with you. I do."
A spark of hope and joy lit up Chloe's eyes, making them look more beautiful. She smiled and hugged him tighter. "Then, Sammy, we can—"
"However, I also feel the same for Diana." Sam cut her off, continuing, "I can't explain it well, but... I'm falling for her. It might be fast or sudden, but... I can see us being together in the future. I'm serious about her."
Just the thought of breaking up with Diana pained Sam. He liked her personality and style and enjoyed spending time with her. Even if there was some suspicion in his mind, he was sure their feelings were mutual.
"It hasn't even been a week, and you already think about being with her in the future?" Chloe raised an eyebrow, clearly surprised by his words, but didn't show any jealousy or anger. Instead, she smirked playfully and nuzzled his neck. "Hmm, then... as I've said before, you can have both. Your stepsister and girlfriend. Why choose one when you can have both, Sammy? Besides... we'll keep our relationship in the dark, so no one will find out. Sounds good?"
The way she suggested was like Alia had proposed to him last night. It seemed both women had the same idea. Which could work, right? Since Sam was already in a secret relationship with Alia, adding Chloe wouldn't change anything, would it?
Well, except that there was now a higher risk of getting caught. This was especially true because Chloe and Alia might suspect something if they noticed Sam paying more attention to one of them.
Still, Sam couldn't resist the temptation. He was already in too deep to back out now. The idea of having both of them for himself was too appealing.
But before making any decisions, Sam had one more concern.
"You said it's fine if I date both of you. But... do you think I feel the same way? That I can stay silent watching you and Jake being intimate together? That I can accept your relationship with him without any jealousy or hurt when we have something special between us?"
It was the same when he saw Jake with Diana, his girlfriend. He didn't like it, not one bit. But he decided to give Diana the benefit of the doubt, considering they just started dating.
However, with Chloe, it was different. Jake was her official boyfriend, and Sam had no right to interfere with that relationship, regardless of whether they decided to pursue a secret one.
Just thinking about it made Sam feel uncomfortable and possessive.
He wasn't usually this way. But the fact that Chloe loved him made his feelings change towards her. It made him more emotional and territorial.
He also realized how selfish it was to demand such a thing when he himself had a secret lover, Alia, and a girlfriend, Diana. It was hypocritical. But he couldn't help how he felt.
Meanwhile, Chloe giggled softly as she listened to Sam's worries. She found it cute that he was getting possessive of her. It meant that he cared and was serious about being with her.
"Well, I have to admit it'll be a bit hard for you to accept it." She cupped his cheek and looked into his eyes with sincerity. "But, believe me, whatever I do or show with Jake is not comparable to what we'll do together. Our bond is deeper and stronger than that. I don't feel anything deep or real for him. It's just physical attraction and some fun. Besides... if it makes you too jealous, you can always punish me."
She ended her sentence with a mischievous wink that hinted at something sexual. Then she leaned forward and nibbled his earlobe. "So, are you convinced? Because I won't wait any longer. I want you now."
Fuck, the way she said it turned Sam on. She was irresistible, no doubt.
"It means you don't plan to stop seeing Jake?" Sam asked as his hand caressed her bare back. "You're going to continue as my 'sister' and his 'girlfriend,' huh?"
Chloe giggled again and licked his ear. "I will dump him if you dump Diana. How about that?"
Sam had no intention of doing so, so he knew he had no right to demand the same from Chloe.
And so, after a moment of silence, Sam sighed in resignation. "Damn, I can't believe I'm doing this. But, fuck it. Let's go for it. You win, Chloe."
The moment he said those words, Chloe squealed happily and kissed him passionately on the lips. Sam responded by wrapping his arms around her and kissing her back. It was deep and hungry, as if they were devouring each other's mouths.
While they kissed, their hands explored each other's bodies freely. Chloe ran her hands over Sam's muscular back and shoulders, feeling his strength, while Sam groped her round ass and breasts, squeezing them possessively.
Read 50+ More Chapters by Subscribing on Subscribe Star.
https://subscribestar.art/midnight_tales/