Chapter 46
"Why deny it, Sammy? Just admit it. I make you horny as hell, and you want to fuck me as hard as you can." Chloe licked her lips and gave him a seductive look. "I promise it'll be our little secret. Like a harmless, fun game. You like games, don't you?"
"Damn it, Chloe. You were scheming this all along, weren't you? Getting a shower with me, giving a handjob, and sleeping with me naked. Everything was planned to lead to this, right?" Sam pushed her away from him and sat up on the bed.
He felt both angry and disappointed at her actions. She was taking advantage of him and the situation to force something out of him. Something he didn't know how to deal with. She was making everything worse.
On one side, Sam loved his family and didn't want to ruin everything because of his desires and feelings. He didn't want to be all alone in this world without anyone to care about or love him.
Yet on the other side, he had already gone too far with his feelings and desires for Alia. They had already decided to pursue their secret relationship, no matter how wrong it was.
The same thing applied to Chloe. He was getting attracted to her as a woman despite trying to fight it. And he had a feeling that sooner or later, he would end up sleeping with her too. Which he feared because it would only complicate things.
Chloe frowned at his sudden reaction and crossed her arms under her breasts, making them more prominent.
"Oh, please. Don't act like you didn't enjoy what happened. I'm not the only one to blame here, you know."
"And who said it was a plan? I'm just doing what I feel in the moment. If anything, shouldn't you appreciate someone being attracted to you? Not many guys get to have a beautiful stepsister like me."
"Ahhh... Damn it. Why are you making this so difficult for me? I never said you're not beautiful. I also didn't say I don't like what happened. You're fucking gorgeous and sexy, and touching you makes me go insane." Sam admitted as he raked his hair in frustration.
"But that's the fucking problem! How can I look at you normally after crossing lines? And how am I supposed to be loyal to my girlfriend if you keep seducing me like this? It's goddamn torture, you know."
It was true. His cock was hard and aching because of her. He wanted to shove it into her mouth and pussy and fuck her brains out right here and now. He had that desire, that temptation. But he also had guilt and fear. It was like a battle between his mind and body. And he was losing it.
"Ah, I see." Chloe smiled at Sam's confession and leaned forward, wrapping her arms around his neck again. She kissed his cheek tenderly. "I didn't know you felt so strongly for me. But you should know that you're also torturing me, right? I've liked you for a long time. You made my heart race like no other. So, after all these years of holding back, I can't take it anymore. I want you, Sam. More than anyone else. That's why I want us to take a step further, to explore our desires."
When Sam heard Chloe's words, his eyes widened slightly. She was serious. She was serious about wanting him, more than just as a step-brother. It was same as he felt for Alia. That longing to be together, to love and be loved.
Moreover, Sam never really considered that Chloe might feel the same all this time. She was always joking and teasing, making him think she didn't have any real interest in him beyond their sibling bond. That it was just fun and games for her. Which was why he never gave much thought to it.
But now, after hearing her confession, everything changed.
'Fuck. She's really in love with me. Just like how I'm in love with my stepmom.'
Sam felt his heart squeeze at the thought. He was so conflicted. It was one thing to love Alia and pursue her. It was already a challenge in itself.
But Chloe? She was his younger stepsister. They had grown up together. She had a boyfriend. He was dating someone else. And he had promised Alia to be with her in secret.
There were too many obstacles and complications.
"Chloe... I don't know what to say." Sam sighed as he held her waist gently. "I really don't know how to deal with this. I never thought you'd feel this way about me, and honestly... I don't want to hurt you. Or Diana. But..."
"But you have desires for me too, right?" Chloe completed his sentence. She smiled softly and caressed his face. "You want to touch me, to fuck me, to feel me cum on your cock. Just like how I want to suck and ride your big, beautiful dick."
Before Sam could deny it or explain himself further, Chloe continued. "However, I don't just have physical needs. I also love you emotionally. As a man and as my brother. It might be wrong or twisted in your eyes, but it's true for me. You're the only one who understands me, supports me, and cares for me unconditionally. I want to be with you always. No matter what."
"Chloe... don't you realize we're siblings? And you have a boyfriend." Sam tried to reason with her.
"Yeah, yeah. I know that. But who says we can't love each other? And about Jake, honestly... I'm not even sure if I really love him or not. Maybe it was just a crush, and I only went out with him because I wanted to distract myself from my feelings for you. He's a nice guy, but not someone special for me. You're the special one." Chloe pecked Sam's lips lightly, showing her affection. "So... do you want to make this a thing? Or do you want to keep pretending and avoiding me?"
Read 45+ More Chapters by Subscribing on Subscribe Star.
https://subscribestar.art/midnight_tales/