074: Since when…?
**Chapter 74**
I curled my finger and executed a ‘Come here’ motion with my finger in her ass, which caused Sasha to become excited.
“HHnngg!!!”
She was still in discomfort because I hadn’t applied any mana or lube. With the [Cleanse] skill, I cleaned her asshole and my hand, so there was no chance of getting an infection. I also liked to keep things natural, so there was nothing else added.
As soon as I felt her getting used to this move, I moved on to the next one. To be honest, I didn’t really know what I was doing because I had to come up with ideas on the spot. I only paid close attention to Sasha’s response to know if I was going in the right direction.
Then I began to touch her inner walls and rub them. I was uncertain as to whether it had any effect, but it did cause Sasha to unconsciously clench down on my finger.
“Aheung!”
Even though she still sounded uncomfortable, I could tell she had started to enjoy it because she was gyrating her ass on my hand and shaking her hips slightly.
That tight canal was unbelievably tight, and I had to admit that I wouldn’t be able to get out of it in one piece if I didn’t get it ready first for my member.
“Haa...”
After I felt her ass getting used to it, I sped up and slowly went as deep as the two knuckles of my forefinger. I moved my finger again and got up once I was sure she wasn’t in as much pain as before.
She turned to look at me, still facedown as she asked, “You done alrea—Haaa!!!”
Her question was answered in an instant as I entered her ass once again with my middle finger. I used a lot more pressure this time than the last time, which made her grunt in pain and take a deep breath.
I repeated the ‘Come here’ gesture by curling my finger and simultaneously touching the walls of her anal cavity. To be honest, that was as far as my imagination would go, so I chose to give her some additional stimulation to allow her to feel better.
I put out my hand and grabbed her beautiful left tit, which was pressed against the bed. After holding it for a few seconds, I moved to the erect milk bead and gave it a tiny pinch.
“Hnn~~”
That was a moan, even though it sounded a little uncomfortable. At least she began to enjoy it. So I said, “You haven’t answered me yet, Sasha,” since she was now enjoying it and all the joy belonged to us. “What would happen if we were ever caught doing what we’re doing?”
“Ahn~~~ I’ll say you jumped me,” she said as a moan came out of her mouth. I gave her nipple a little twist, causing her to yell in mild pain.
“Kya!”
“What was that for?” she said, turning to face me with a cute frown on her face while my finger remained in her ass, and her nipple was still between my fingers.
“Be serious,” I replied.
“Again. A bit difficult to do that with your finger… up my ass. And now it’s starting to… to feel good… too,” she replied. Even though she had a good point, I pushed my finger in deeper until it was buried deep inside her asshole.
“Hooo!!!” She again exhaled deeply as my finger was fully buried in her ass, my hand resting on her ass cheek.
“Then you’d better start taking it seriously. Otherwise, I might just have to add another finger.” I said this while moving my finger inside her and making her grunt and moan at the same time.
“Aagghh~~”
She took a few seconds to recuperate before she sighed and responded, “I will simply say that I started the entire thing.”
“Not good enough,” I replied. I wasn’t trying to push the blame on her. I needed her reason for doing this.
Even though I had already asked her why she was attracted to me and her response was adequate at the time, I needed to know if it was sufficient for her now that things had changed and I was dealing with a serious situation involving her older sister and her mother. If she went through with it, she might not be able to go back.
“Hmm~~~”
Sasha moaned and slightly shook her ass before turning to look at me again. This time, she replied with a deeper expression in her eyes, “I am going to say I love you… and I don’t care what the world… thinks of our relationship as long as you don’t abandon me.”
Thump!
Even though her reply was like it was taken from a movie dialogue, my heart thumped a bit. The L-word alone was enough to get me going this time, and I could tell it was the truth. But I had to contain myself. She needed to be aware that there were other people involved, and I had no idea what the future held.
I could have done nothing and tried to keep up with everyone at the same time, but I knew that would put a lot of people in danger. I was hesitant to cause her any harm now that she had referenced the word “love,” as lust was no longer a part of us. Well, not a significant part of us anyway.
I retracted my finger and completely backed away.
“Hey! What now?!” Sasha asked as she turned around fully to complain.
“Before you do anything else, I need to tell you something,” I said.
“What?” she asked in an annoyed tone.
“You’re not the only one,” I replied.
“Haa?” She regarded me with the same incredulity as if I were the dumbest creature on Earth. “Of course I am aware that I am not the only one. You think I didn’t know that before I started to make a move on you?”
“No,” I replied. “You were the only one then, but you’re not now.”
“...” Before asking, she took a moment to consider the situation, as if a light bulb turned on in her head. She asked, “Oh, you mean Mom and Sara?”
“Yea—” I was about to reply when I froze.
“What?” My voice was the size of a mosquito when I asked that question.
“What? You thought I didn’t know? Sara’s been masturbating almost her whole life with your name on her lips. I’ve heard her enough to know. And it wasn’t a surprise when you two banged. What? You think just because Mom left, you were safe that night?”
There was that look again.
The look of looking at the dumbest creature on the planet.
“And Mom. Dude, you think we’re all stupid. I mean, Mira might not have a clue because she doesn’t care what goes on around the house, but I don’t hear Mom and Dad going at it for months, and suddenly she’s broadcasting to the entire house? Not to mention, if you don’t want to be found, don’t do it in the kitchen.”
She was going nonstop for a while before she finally stopped and asked, “You lose yourself when you’re in heat, Tyler. Even Sara was watching you doing the nasty from the living room. You couldn’t even tell when she was in plain view.”
“And why do you think I was here down to my birthday suit when anybody could have walked in? There are only Sara and Mom at home, so I could leverage their activities to my advantage if it were them.”
“Are you really that much of an idiot, Tyler?”
She continuously spoke, each word striking me like a concrete slab. I could tell from experience that it was not a pleasant experience.
“Si-since when did you know?” I asked.
“Last night when you were with Mom. I figured it all out when I saw Sara acting that way in the morning. She’s like that when she’s upset with you, isn’t she? I had a hunch why she would be upset with you,” Sasha replied.
“Then why?” I inquired, but found myself unable to complete the sentence as she approached me. We were both on our knees, and she wrapped her arms around me and gazed deeply into my eyes. “Because I love you.”
Hearing it again was massively painful. You heard me right. Painful. I was the biggest jerk on planet Earth.
“Don’t think too deeply, Tyler,” Sasha said as she rolled her eyes and pulled me out before I could wallow anymore in guilt.
“We’re still young. Not to mention we’re a family. There’s a good chance it might not work out in the future. But I don’t want to think about tomorrow and lose today. Let’s keep things the same for now. Once we know how we want each other in the future, when maybe sharing isn’t enough, I may bring this up again, but that time we’ll do it like adults, not kids who are just starting out in this world.”
For an ???-year-old, her words were very mature. Or at least I thought so until...
“So? Are we gonna focus on my ass now or what? Because it felt really, really good.”
~~
Let me know if there are any issues.