Chapter 36: The Headmaster’s Justice
Disclaimer:
Harry Potter and all of its characters belong to J.K. Rowling.
I own nothing but the original characters I make.
"Dialogue"
'Thoughts'
-Author notes-
Chapter 36: The Headmaster's Justice
The cell had no windows except the small, barred opening high in the wall.
Harry watched the faint light of dawn creep through the iron grille, painting thin stripes across the stone floor.
He had been here for hours. How many, he could not exactly say. It was hard to keep track of time in this place.
His arms ached. The magical ropes had not loosened. They held him tight, biting into his wrists and chest with every shallow breath. The damp hay beneath him smelled of mould and decay. His robes were still wet from the lake, clinging to his skin like a frozen blanket.
He had tried to sleep, but the cold would not let him. He had tried to call out to his friends, but the thick stone walls swallowed his voice. Only silence answered.
'How long will they keep me here?' he wondered. 'A day? A week? Until I die?'
He thought of his friends, trapped in their own cells. He remembered the look of despair on Pansy's face when he last saw her. She had a desperate need to see her brother one last time.
'They took that away from her,' Harry thought. 'They took her last chance to say goodbye.'
All of a sudden, the lock of his door clicked.
Harry was startled. He had not heard any footsteps approaching. Then he realised that perhaps the room was enchanted to block all sounds, which would explain why he never heard any of his friends.
He looked towards the door as the heavy oak door swung open, and torchlight flooded the cell.
Professor McGonagall stood in the doorway. Her crimson robes were immaculate as always, her dark hair pulled into its severe bun. She held her wand in her right hand, firmly gripped.
Behind her, two Junior Inquisitors lurked in the shadows. They were not the Weasley twins, but older students Harry did not recognise.
"Remove the ropes," McGonagall commanded.
One of the Inquisitors stepped forward and flicked his wand. The enchanted ropes slithered off Harry's body like dead snakes, coiling on the floor. Harry gasped as blood rushed back into his numb limbs. He rubbed his wrists, wincing at the raw, red marks left behind.
"Stand up, Mr. Potter," McGonagall said.
Harry rose slowly, his legs unsteady. He leaned against the cold stone wall for support. "Where are my friends?"
McGonagall's thin lips pressed together. "You should be more concerned about yourself."
"I asked where my friends are." Harry's voice was hoarse, but he did not look away from her cold eyes.
For a moment, something flickered in McGonagall's expression...surprise, perhaps, or irritation. Then it was gone.
"Mr. Malfoy and Mr. Crabbe have been dealt with," she said. "They have lost one credit point each and will serve detention for the remainder of the school year. They are fortunate that the Headmaster chose to intervene and show leniency personally. If it were up to me, they would have been expelled for this."
Harry's chest tightened. "And Pansy?"
McGonagall was silent.
"Professor," Harry pressed, his voice rising. "Where is Pansy?"
McGonagall's jaw tightened. "Miss Parkinson's circumstances are… different. Unlike ordinary students, who begin with three credit points, Miss Parkinson and her brother were admitted to Hogwarts under special conditions. As the children of a convicted criminal, they started with only one credit point each."
Harry's blood ran cold. He remembered the history book. Alistair and his newborn daughter, Pansy, were permitted to attend Hogwarts under supervision.
The school must have placed harsh conditions on them, but Pansy never complained or even mentioned this. Harry realised how brave she was.
Every time they broke the rules, the risks were much higher for her, but she did it anyway.
"She lost that point last night," McGonagall continued. "Therefore, she has been sent for re‑education."
The world seemed to stop.
Re‑education.
Harry had learned as much as he could about this. Re‑education was supposed to be a course designed to correct behavioural deficiencies...at least, that was how it was explained in the books.
But every student knew there was more to it. He had heard nasty rumours about what went on in there. That they locked you in a basement and forced you to drink all sorts of potions. That wizards used their magic to dig through your head until they found the thoughts they didn't like. That the few who returned from re‑education were never the same.
"No," Harry whispered. "You can't do that to her. She didn't do anything wrong –"
"She broke the rules," McGonagall said flatly. "She trespassed in a restricted area. She used an illegal potion. She swam in the Black Lake after curfew. She associated with known troublemakers." Her eyes bore into Harry. "The rules apply to everyone, Mr. Potter. Especially to the daughters of traitors."
Harry felt sick. "Where is she? Where did they take her?"
"That is not your concern."
"She's my friend!"
McGonagall stepped closer, her wand still raised. "Your friend broke the law. She must face the consequences. And you, Mr. Potter, must face yours." She gestured to the door. "The Headmaster wishes to see you. He will determine your punishment personally."
Harry did not move. "I'm not going anywhere until you tell me what happened to Pansy."
McGonagall's eyes narrowed. "You are in no position to make demands."
"Then call the Inquisitors," Harry said. "Drag me. But I won't take another step until you answer me."
The two Inquisitors behind McGonagall shifted uneasily. McGonagall herself was very still, her wand tip aimed at Harry's chest.
For a long, tense moment, no one spoke.
Then McGonagall sighed...a small, almost imperceptible sound. "Miss Parkinson was taken to the Ministry last night. She will undergo a standard re‑education course. If she completes it successfully, she will be allowed to return to Hogwarts with one credit point. If she plays her cards right, she may still have a chance of a future."
"And if she doesn't?"
McGonagall did not answer.
Harry's hands curled into fists. "Let me see her."
"That is not possible."
"Then let me write to her."
"You will do nothing of the sort." McGonagall's voice hardened. "You will come with me to the Headmaster's office, or I will have you carried there. Now choose."
Harry stared at her. He wanted to fight and scream at her. But he knew, deep down, that it would change nothing.
He walked towards the door.
The walk to the Headmaster's office was silent.
McGonagall led the way, her heels clicking on the stone floor. The two Inquisitors followed behind Harry, their footsteps echoing in the empty corridors.
The castle was just waking up. Portraits stretched and yawned, and the first rays of sunlight streamed through the high windows, but no one spoke to them. No one even looked.
Meanwhile, Harry's mind was racing. Pansy was gone, and there was nothing he could do to help her.
'I should never have brought her to the cave,' he thought. 'I couldn't keep her safe.'
The guilt pressed on his chest like an anvil.
They climbed the moving staircase, passed the tapestry of the dancing troll, and stopped before the stone gargoyle that guarded the Headmaster's office.
"Sherbet Lemon," McGonagall said.
The gargoyle sprang aside, revealing the spiral staircase behind.
"Go up," McGonagall said. "The Headmaster is waiting for you."
Harry climbed the stairs alone.
The office was exactly as he remembered it, round, cluttered, filled with whirring silver instruments and the portraits of past headmasters.
He had hoped never to come here again. And yet here he was, just a few months later, having to confront this man.
The smell of lemon and old parchment hung in the air.
Albus Dumbledore sat behind his magnificent claw‑footed desk, his white beard flowing down his chest, his pale purple robes shimmering in the morning light. His half‑moon spectacles sat low on his nose, and when he saw Harry, he gave him a grandfatherly smile.
But Harry knew what hid beneath it.
"Ah, Mister Potter," Dumbledore said, gesturing to the wooden chair facing his desk. "Please, come and sit. We have much to discuss. Would you like a sherbet lemon?"
Harry did not sit. He did not answer.
Dumbledore's smile did not waver. He unwrapped a lemon drop for himself and placed it on his tongue, savouring it slowly. "I understand you have had a difficult night. I am sorry for that. Truly."
Harry's hands clenched at his sides. "Why did you send Pansy away?. I am the one responsible for what happened. It was all my idea."
"That is very noble of you, Mister Potter." Dumbledore's voice was soft, almost gentle. "I can tell that you care for her, and that is admirable. But the rules exist for a reason, and she broke them."
"She didn't do anything wrong. I brought her to the lake. I gave her the potion. If anyone should be punished, it's me."
Dumbledore studied him for a long moment. "You are not wrong, Mister Potter. You are the leader of this little insurgency. You supplied the potion. You led them to the cave. You are ultimately responsible." He paused. "And that is why your punishment must be… considered carefully."
Harry waited.
Dumbledore rose from his chair and walked to the window, his back to Harry. "I do not believe in crushing young spirits, Harry. I have seen too many bright flames extinguished by harshness. You have a fire in you...a desire to uncover the truth, a refusal to bow to authority. In many ways, you remind me of myself when I was young."
He turned. His blue eyes were no longer twinkling, but they were not cold either. They were… assessing him...testing him.
"I am going to give you a chance, Harry. A chance to prove that you are more than a rule‑breaker. A chance to channel that fire into something constructive."
"What does that mean?"
Dumbledore walked back to his desk and sat down. "You will lose one credit point. Which means that you now have one remaining after the little incident at the train station." The Headmaster paused and rested his eyes on him for a long moment.
"One more misstep and you will be joining Miss Parkinson in re-education. I trust that you do not want that to happen."
Harry nodded slowly. One point left. One mistake from disappearing.
"In addition," Dumbledore continued, "you will be placed on a curfew of six o'clock. Every evening, you will be in your common room before the hour strikes. No exceptions."
"Yes, sir."
Dumbledore nodded. "Furthermore, you will serve detention for the remainder of the school year with Professor Snape. He has agreed to oversee your… rehabilitation. You will assist him in the dungeons every Saturday and Sunday."
Harry's stomach tightened. Snape. Dumbledore's most trusted professor.
This was not a punishment. This was a tight leash. Snape would report everything back.
"And finally," Dumbledore said, leaning forward, "you will meet with me every Tuesday evening for a personal study session. We will discuss magical theory, ethics, and… the history you seem so eager to uncover."
Harry blinked. "You want to teach me?"
"I want to guide you." Dumbledore's voice was warm and grandfatherly, but there was a sharp edge beneath it. "You are intelligent, Harry. Curious. But you lack context. You see the world in black and white, when in truth it is made of grey. I hope to help you understand the difficult choices that leaders must make."
'Leaders,' Harry thought. 'He means himself. Does he want me to understand why he killed Alistair?...why?'
"Your wand will not be confiscated," Dumbledore added. "I do not believe in disarming a student who wishes to learn. But I will be watching your progress closely."
Harry said nothing. He was trying to process the punishment. It was harsh, but not crushing. And the weekly meetings with Dumbledore… that felt like a trap.
"What about Pansy?" Harry asked. "Can you help her?"
Dumbledore's expression softened...or seemed to. "Miss Parkinson is in the hands of the re‑education department. I cannot simply… wave a wand and free her. The process must run its course." He paused. "However, I will say this: your cooperation, your willingness to prove yourself, may make things… easier for her. The Ministry takes notice of good behaviour, Harry. If you show that you can be trusted, that you can follow the rules, then perhaps I can request a review of her case."
It was a lie. Harry could feel it. A thin, silk‑wrapped lie. But what choice did he have?
"I understand...Sir." Harry said quietly.
Dumbledore smiled. "Good. Then we have an understanding. You may go. Mr Filch, who is waiting right outside the office, will escort you to the dungeons. Your first detention with Professor Snape will be this Saturday morning. And our first study session will be Tuesday evening, after classes."
Harry turned and walked towards the door.
"Oh, and Harry?"
He stopped.
"The third‑floor corridor is still forbidden. I would advise you to stay away from it." Dumbledore's voice was kind. "Not all secrets are meant to be uncovered. Some are meant to protect you."
Harry did not look back. He walked out of the office and down the spiral staircase, his fists clenched at his sides.
Filch was waiting at the bottom.
The caretaker's face was grim, but his eyes...his eyes were sad. He said nothing as he led Harry back to the dungeons. Harry did not speak either.
Pansy was gone. Draco and Crabbe were on thin ice. And Harry himself was walking a razor's edge.
'One more mistake,' he thought. 'One more rule broken. And I may disappear for good.'
When he entered the Slytherin common room, he saw Draco and Crabbe sitting by the fire. Draco's face was pale, his eyes red. Crabbe stared into the flames, his jaw set.
"Harry," Draco said, rising. "What happened? What did Dumbledore say?"
Harry sat down heavily on the sofa. He looked at his friends...at their frightened faces, at the weight of guilt in their eyes.
"We're still here," he said. "But Pansy…"
He could not finish the sentence.
Draco's face crumpled. Crabbe looked away.
And Harry, for the first time since waking up in this twisted world, felt truly alone.
A.N: - Remember to comment, vote, and/or leave a review if you have the time. Those things help me a lot and I would really appreciate it.
You can support me on P@treon if you like and get 10 advanced chapters. You can also find character images to view for free in Collections/Harry Potter: Mirror Images
-.com/Kriogenix
For donations and commissions, go to .com/kriogenix