83: Kerrot Cake (18+)
Of course there was lube in the nightstand.
Part of Alexandra was more shocked at herself for not expecting as much, yet a quick search through the drawers just in case revealed the all-important fluid, along with a contraceptive that wasn’t the birth control potions that Alexandra was now used to seeing. No, it was a small wooden case filled with rubber condoms. The moment of confusion was of course replaced with the mental reminder that the Syndicate still didn’t know for certain how Eris’s Phallus Philters interacted with the magic of normal contraceptive potions just yet. Having Jaxie risk knocking up the highest-value asset of the Syndicate was most definitely a no-go.
The box of condoms was left behind while the bottle of lube was retrieved. Though, Alexandra still wasn’t sure whether she was going to need it for its actual purpose, or to chug the bottle and hope it loosened up the knots in her chest.
Jaxie understood. She seemed to be okay with it. That was good.
Eris seemed to understand, and although teary, acknowledged the problem. Also good.
Then why the FUCK did Alexandra’s heart still feel like a ball bearing was being shoved through an aorta?
They’ll never love you the way you want.
Shut up.
You’re trying to distance yourself to stop the pain, but it isn’t going to work if you’re still going to be with them.
Shut the fuck up.
Calling it something different isn’t going to mean anything as long as everything else stays as it is. The problem won’t be fixed like this, Alexandra. They don’t love you that way, and they never will. You are the extra piece that they don’t need.
Just. Shut. Up.
They’re so blinded by each other that they still don’t understand. They think one little talk is going to make everything okay. But it won’t. Because it can’t. They don’t care how you feel, as long as they get to keep you around. You aren’t their girlfriend, you’re their pet. Their toy. They think they love you but they don’t, and they won’t, and they can’t, and they still have no idea-
Alexandra’s hands clenched into fists so tight that her knuckles popped. Loudly. Jaxie, who was on all fours- gods, that was a sight- looked over her shoulder with a raised eyebrow. “You better not be chickening out on me, big girl. If anyone’s gonna be nervous in this situation, it’d be me.”
Alexandra forced an awkward smile, wringing her hands together. “It’s just… I can’t believe we’re doing this.”
“But I want to believe it,” Eris said almost breathlessly. She was sitting just beside and behind Jaxie, doing the unspeakable act of lubricating the Berserker’s back door. Alexandra knew that all three of them were enjoying that part. Jaxie, on her knees and elbows with a languid smile while Eris poured a healthy dose of lube with one hand and used the other to work it inside the clenched ring. Gods, Eris’s eyes were wide as saucers and the lust on her face was thick like paint while her fingers massaged Jaxie’s other entrance. Alexandra watched a thumb trace around the wrinkled muscle, scooping up spilled liquid before gently sliding inside until the first knuckle disappeared. The fact that Eris was still wearing multiple lines of Alexandra’s release on her face did not help the Knight keep her composure.
Fuck, Jaxie’s butt looked so tight even with just Eris’s thumb, how in Grihm was Alexandra going to fit her cock in that?
You won’t, and you shouldn’t. You don’t want ‘friends with benefits’. But they can’t give you what you want- they said so outright. You. Can’t. Have. Them.
Just stay quiet and smile. You’re the tank- you’re supposed to be the one getting hurt.
Going first so that everyone else can be happy while you get broken? That’s not how you live. Focus on yourself. Let others get hurt for you. Love someone who will actually love you back. You deserve that, and you won’t get that from them.
“You know, you can work with Ell to help get me all warmed up,” Jaxie grinned over her shoulder- long hair draping beside her head. “Don’t worry, it doesn’t bite.”
Alexandra gulped as Jaxie wiggled her hips, shaking both the rounded, athletic ass pointed directly at the Knight and the lengthy cock pointed directly downwards with the rigidity of rebar. It even moved Eris’s hand in the process, her thumb still squeezed into the passageway and being brought for the ride.
You should have just stayed quiet back in the Obelisk. If you didn’t point out Eris and Jaxie’s favoritism, you could still be pretending like you’re their third half. That’s good enough.
You don’t deserve a pretend, fake love- you deserve honest, truthful love of your own. Breaking up with them was the right choice, but you need to follow through with it. Don’t be their sex toy- just be their friend. Leave.
Alexandra herself found it quite difficult to pick a side in her internal war. She wanted them. She wanted Jaxie and Eris so badly that it drove nails through her bloodstream. She loved them so much and even considering the idea of not being with them was agony in itself. She needed them. Alexandra also wanted to be loved. A genuine, balanced love from someone who felt the exact same way about her. No extra wheel. Just a perfectly even give-and-take of connection. Love she could spend the rest of her life with. Love that she could be old and grey, but still holding hands and getting butterflies in her stomach just because of a warm smile.
Jaxie and Eris, or love. For the first time in a while, the two sides of her internal conflict were in unison.
You can’t have both. One or the other. Make your choice.
So she did.
Alexandra scooched forward on her knees and placed both hands on Jaxie’s bottom. Her skin was almost hot to the touch, but just as silky smooth. Furthermore, Alexandra could feel every tendon of the muscle beneath the surface. As her fingers squeezed the perfect globes, the skin’s pliability fought back with resistance from that same muscle. Pushing her hands apart revealed more of the tight ring that Eris was avidly probing with her thumb, both girls now pressed together while they played with the third’s butt. Jaxie, meanwhile, let her head hang with complacent noises eeking out repeatedly. If those weren’t enough, the extremely erect shaft hanging downwards was idly twitching with beads of precum forming at the tip, dangling, then dropping onto the sheets before a new one leaked out. The arousal was almost too much to bear- so thick that Alexandra could practically taste it in the air.
The noise of approval from Jaxie when one of Alexandra’s hands drifted closer to the center, brushing knuckles against the digits that Eris was using to toy with the hole, was delicious. Even more so when Alexandra gently dragged a fingertip over the wrinkled muscle clinging onto Eris’s thumb. Jaxie purred.
“Go ahead- see how tight I am. Just for you, Alex.”
Alexandra forced the bickering internal voices silent, letting every part of this moment consume her focus. Eyes stared unblinking while she slid her own thumb right beside Eris’s. For a moment, she waited for the redhead to leave the path so that Alexandra could enter, but she quickly realized that wasn’t going to happen. Instead, Eris almost seemed to be pulling her thumb inwards and to the side. As if trying to make space for Alexandra to join her. The Knight gulped.
With a few circular passes to try and gather as much of the slick lube on her digits as possible, Alexandra finally let her thumb come to rest back on the puckered ring. Then, she started pushing. Gently- of course.
Jaxie let out a noise almost between a purr and a gasp as the tight, virginal muscle was pried open around a second thumb. Alexandra, on the other hand, could only marvel at the feeling. It was hot and wet, just like Eris and Bailey’s pussies, but gods was it tight. So tight- squeezing down on her thumb as she slid it in further and further until the ring of Jaxie’s colon felt like a rope tied around the base of Alexandra’s finger. Jaxie chuckled- the laughter going through her entire body in a way that Alexandra could now feel squeezing her thumb.
“Mmm, this is gonna be good. Care to replace those fingers with something a little meatier?”
This time, Eris piped up. “Hold on, we need to make sure you’re loosened up. It-...” Eris paused. “We don’t want it to hurt.”
Jaxie glanced over at Eris in a way that sent daggers cutting across Alexandra’s heart. She wanted to have Jaxie look at her that way. So much softness in the eyes. So much care despite the wicked grin. Alexandra shoved it down while Jaxie winked.
“I’ll be fine. I’m a big girl. I know what I can and can’t handle. And you-”
Her eyes focused back onto Alexandra, eyebrows waggling. “You can pretend this is one of our sparring matches if you want. Let’s see which of us can still walk when we’re done, eh?”
Just a sparring match between best friends.
Just friends.
Best friends.
Alexandra put on a smile despite the blush in her cheeks, nodded, and even offered a tiny joke. “First to three wins?”
Jaxie grinned. “We’ll see.”
While Jaxie shimmied her legs a little bit further apart to lower her butt a few inches, Alexandra lifted from sitting on her feet to properly kneeling. Now, her nethers were at the perfect height for the act, and she used the thumb still hooked in Jaxie’s butt to help line both of them up. Eris pulled her own thumb free as Alexandra did the same- replacing it with the tip of her cock pressing up against the ring. Not enough to penetrate or even attempt to- just resting it there in a moment of hesitation. Jaxie wiggled her butt, making her cock dangle and giving another dazzling smile over her shoulder.
“Just remember that I’m a Berserker,” she said. “If I can get stung by a giant scorpion and walk it off, I can take whatever you give me.”
Eris blinked. “Wait- what?” Alexandra cleared her throat.
“Uhh… some weird stuff happened to us when we went into the Obelisk before you shoved everyone out.”
“And we’ll talk about it later-” Jaxie cut in, pressing her butt a bit more insistently against Alexandra’s erection. “-With the Syndicate and everyone else while we work out the next moves. But right now, they want to get a good test of all your skills, including Desire’s Reap, and I want Alex to shove that fat dick of hers so far up my ass that I glaze this bed.”
Alexandra throbbed at those words. Then, Eris glanced upwards to the Knight with big, beautiful green eyes and a premature cumshot still sticking to her face. “Do it. Please.”
She damned near came again, which would have been even more embarrassing. Instead, Alexandra settled for pushing her hips forward with a slow but insistent pressure. The lubricated force dragging against her cockhead felt like she were trying to shove her fist through the sleeve of a shirt twenty sizes too small, yet a thousand times more pleasurable. So much friction and squeezing as the ring of Jaxie’s colon dragged over the sensitive tip, more and more and-
The last of the head finally popped through with a noise that was almost audible, but not really since both Alexandra and Jaxie were groaning. A moment of pause let Alexandra look down and see both her hands gripping tightly onto Jaxie’s hips, and Jaxie’s own hands practically clawing holes through the sheets. The Berserker breathed heavily. “So… fucking… big.”
“Now you know how I feel…” Eris muttered, though the girl almost looked dazed. She was now sitting cross-legged, with one hand idly moving between her thighs. The other, however, rested just on top of Alexandra’s that was holding the Berserker’s hip. Her eyes were locked, unblinking on the connection between the two combatants. Alexandra’s own attention was snapped back to Jaxie when she wiggled her butt just slightly to stir them both.
“I know you- fuck...- I know you still have a lot more, and I want all of it. You won’t break me. Keep going.”
Alexandra swallowed deeply, nodded, readjusted her grip, then resumed pushing.
Oh, it felt amazing.
Again, just like the cores of both Eris and Bailey, but there was a distinct tightness here that the others lacked. This wasn’t a massage to milk out Alexandra’s load. This was wringing every drop out of a damp towel by twisting it over and over and over again. It was pressure that was almost too much to handle- to the point that it very nearly hurt, but most definitely in no way that it would ever drown out the sensation of pleasure. Inch after inch of thick meat was slowly crammed into a space that felt like half the size as Alexandra leaned forward while tugging Jaxie back.
Meanwhile, Jaxie had actually grabbed a small pillow and pulled it in between her arms to where she could bury her face into something soft. That didn’t stop her groans and whines from eeking out into the air. Eris leaned forward.
“Are you okay? Do you need to-”
Alexandra didn’t hear the rest of Eris’s question. In fact, she lost all comprehension that the girl even asked one because Jaxie chose that moment to rock her hips backwards with all the force of a Berserker and then some. It actually made Alexandra wonder if Jaxie had somehow built up a little bit of Rage because of how much pressure pushed back against her.
What had been half of a girthy slab of meat stuffed in a tiny hole turned into all of it in the blink of an eye. For a moment, everything was warmth. Everything was heat. Everything was pulsing and twitching and rippling walls squeezing so hard it could probably castrate people not durable enough to handle it. But Alexandra could.
Because Alexandra was the tank.
It was actually a little hard to notice the ropes of creamy white spraying from Jaxie’s loose, flailing cock and painting the sheets underneath her. That was because Alexandra was releasing her own streams of fluid to join in the mess of lube that had been stuffed into Jaxie’s rear hole. The muscles in her abdomen were straining, pulling taught and releasing, taught and releasing, over and over and over while balls boiled in orgasm that seemed to continue far beyond the length it normally should.
The pleasured groans of both girls sounded all through the bedroom, and even into the ears of a fully armoured bodyguard in the far corner of the room that Alexandra honestly forgot existed in this moment. That was because that woman wasn’t important. The only thing that was important right now was Jaxie’s ass, and the fact it was holding a death grip on her cock to tear out any and every drop of seed possible.
Eventually though, the pulsing ceased. The throbbing lessened, the ropes quit firing, and breathing became less ragged. Alexandra just held tight onto Jaxie’s hips for stability, still buried to the very hilt in the ass of her girlfri-... of her best friend. Eyes flicked beside her to Eris who was staring like a woman drowning of thirst beholding a rainstorm. Eris even licked her lips before she began moving.
“Woah, where are you goin-” Jaxie began, but Eris cut her off.
“You’re doing that again with me under you.” The redhead vanished beneath Jaxie’s body, seemingly unbothered by the fact that the bed in that spot had literally just been made a mess of. Then, Alexandra could only see Eris’s limbs reach up to wrap around Jaxie’s torso and practically pull the tall girl down, which in turn brought Alex with her.
That, of course, yanked an almost visceral reaction of pleasured whines from the two futas still joined together as they fell on top of the Artificer. Now, it was even harder to try and see Eris, buried underneath a pile of Jaxie. It didn’t stop Alexandra from hearing Eris mumble up to the Berserker.
“Fuck me while she fucks you.”
Jaxie laughed- which again, Alexandra could feel shuddering through her cock. “Alright, but I need you to do something for me, first.”
“Anything,” Eris said. “Please- I need it. I’ll do anything.”
Jaxie nuzzled her face downwards into a fluff of red hair, which was the only thing Alexandra could see of Eris.
“I like the enthusiasm, sweetie,” Jaxie chuckled. “And I’ll make sure to remember it for next time. Right now though, I don’t need anything like that from you.”
A hidden Eris made a confused noise, and Alexandra could picture the puzzled look on the redhead’s face. She could also picture the way Jaxie probably rolled her eyes before planting a kiss atop Eris’s head.
“I was just gonna ask you to grab that box of condoms. Don’t need to make a third person pregnant this week.”
The room fell quiet as everyone but Jaxie froze. The next voices were both Eris and Alexandra in uncanny unison.
”Uhh… what?”
Jaxie offered a shrug. “Welcome home surprise?”
