Godsforsaken

Four gorgeous women arrayed before me, dripping and ready. A conqueror's feast, Alisha had called it. And that's certainly what it felt like. All of them hot for me, all of them waiting for me to lavish attention on them, all of them trying in their own way to entice me. Yume's undulating tails, Anna sneaking a hand between her legs in anticipation, Selene arching her back to show her ass off and Alisha leaning down even further, pressing her cheek into the mattress, making herself look as submissive as possible. But how to go about it?

I had been with Anna and Selene last night so there was the temptation to make them go last. There was also the possibility of just going in order from left to right, though it would make me predictable. Alisha being the little brat that she was she might even get whiny once she realized she was going last. There was also the hygiene concern that made me want to save Anna and Yume for last. Powdered unicorn horn supposedly took care of that but I never fully trusted that and it was just a good habit not to break. Decisions, decisions.

Finally I decided on a course of action. I took my spot behind the chosen girl and, with a single rough thrust, buried myself inside of Yume's juicy pussy.

“Ahhnn~” she moaned and it would have sounded theatrical if I hadn't felt her pussy clamping down on me like a closed fist.

“No fair,” Alisha whined and just for that I was going to make her wait a little bit longer.

Yume was so wet. That spiel she'd given me about how proud of me she was and how wet it had made her had been absolutely true. She was always wet and ready for me, her pussy always dripping and perfuming the room with her scent, but tonight it was even more pronounced than normal. Her insides undulated around me and my cock scraped more and more of her juices out of her on every pass, all the while her pussy practically tried to strangle me, trying to milk me for all I was worth.

“I thought you wanted my ass,” she moaned, her tails gently batting at me.

In response I grabbed hold of her cheeks and spread them apart. Anna had prepared her so thoroughly that her cute little hole was gaping open slightly, twitching as the cool air hit it. “Don't worry,” I growled, “I will. But how can you expect me not to fuck this pussy if it's gushing for me like this?”

In response she threw her hips back against me even harder. “Irresistible, am I?”

“You know you are,” I growled and started laying into her even harder. I wasn't trying to cum, not yet. Oh, a single orgasm wouldn't be enough to satisfy me tonight, but I wasn't going to just give in immediately.

And so I actively held back, focusing on her pleasure, grinding into her exactly the way I knew she loved it, forcing the climax out of her.

“No fair,” she whined when she realized what I was doing. But I didn't stop. I kept going, kept working her, kept enjoying her huge fluff balls batting at me as they wagged, kept going until she was reduced to babbling in her mother tongue, the one I couldn't make heads or tails of. When I could tell she was almost at her limit I pressed both thumbs into her cute little hole and started to stretch her, ever so gently.

She went insane. She shrieked out her pleasure in a language the Elysian Fields had likely never heard before, her pussy clamping down on my cock even harder if that was possible. But I didn't let her ride that high. I pulled out of her, making her clamp down on nothing but air, then shifted on the bed and crammed my cock inside Selene's pussy.

“Oh fuck yes,” she groaned. Her asshole twitched at me, almost begging me to rethink my original plan and play with it instead but I held fast. Her pussy felt incredible anyway, soaking wet and so tight. I played with it so rarely that it always felt like a new experience, not only a sensation I was never used to but also always nearly as tight as the first time. She didn't struggle to take me but the fluttery breath she let out when I pulled out was telling enough.

Now that I wasn't giving it to Yume there were no fluffy tails to distract me, letting me look my girls over. Anna had graduated from a tentative hand between her legs to frigging herself as she watched us, her expression filled with desire and jealousy. Yume was out cold, breathing like a bellows, a faint line of drool coming out of her mouth. And Alisha?

Alisha was staring at us wide-eyed, sucking on two of her fingers, desperate to be included in any way. Oh, she would be. Momentarily.

I started laying into Selene harder. A benefit to so rarely playing with her pussy was that the paladin was a bit of a lightweight when it came to that. I didn't have to try very hard to turn her into putty. I simply leaned forward, pushed two fingers into her mouth and started fucking her a little slower, pumping the fingers into her mouth in time with my thrusts. Her moans turned into unintelligible gurgles almost immediately and I felt her muscles quiver every time I ground my hips into her.

The moment she came I pulled out, leaving her quivering and gasping. I was getting close myself and I knew exactly where the load had to go.

“Oh goddess, YES!” Alisha shrieked as I hilted myself inside her. It had been far too long since I had last filled her up and I had missed it. Her pussy always felt like it was made for me and fucking her right after the others made the description even more apt. Her insides fit me like a glove, clamping down around me in just the right way, taking me so perfectly.

Her body was putty underneath me before I even started working her sweet spots, as if just the act of causing me pleasure brought her close to orgasm. Sometimes I wondered if that might actually be true, that we were so compatible that she derived her pleasure from mine. But then again, when she provoked me enough to make me spank her, that was all for her benefit.

But that wasn't what this was about. I was using her for my own pleasure, rutting into her barely responsive body, her insides churning around me, and yet she was losing her mind from it. Again and again she came, the orgasms feeding into each other, and the only reason I could even tell that was because I had become so familiar with her reaction.

From the way Anna was staring at us going at it I wasn't even sure if she could tell that the intermittent moans and sobs meant Alisha was currently losing her mind.

I could feel my own peak approaching and did the thing I knew would drive her wild all over again. I leaned down, crushing her beneath my weight, and kissed her. The position was awkward, especially with her cheek still pressed against the mattress, but it didn't matter. The moment my lips touched hers she let out a squeal that reminded me of a boiling kettle and her pussy clamped down on me as if trying to wring out my seed. And I obliged her.

I pumped her full, losing count of the number of spurts I sprayed inside her, painting her insides white as she lost her mind, just enjoying the feeling of absolutely dominating her.

When I was spent I took a few moments to just lay there, feeling her clammy skin against mine, long enough that when I got up I practically had to peel myself off of her. But I managed. I dragged my cock, still covered in a layer of thick white cream, out of her well-fucked hole, circled around the bed and then crawled onto it in front of them, admiring their gorgeous faces rather than their gorgeous backsides.

I wasn't hard yet but looking at them, three girls absolutely ruined and one desperately frigging herself, I wasn't entirely soft anymore either. And the moment I presented them with my cock covered in Alisha's and my juices, Selene and Anna descended upon it.